Manhattan 5 lb Chapter 13 Question 26

This question is from Manhattan 5LB Book of GRE Practice Problem in Chapter 13:

  1. If x is divisible by 18 and y is divisible by 12, which of the following statements must be
    true?
    Indicate all such statements.

x + y is divisible by 6
xy is divisible by 48
x/y is divisible by 6

How is I the only one that is true?

got both I, II as true statements. However, the book said only I is correct

a multiple of 18 is 36 and a multiple of 12 is 24. When I plug it into statement II I get 864. I then divide by 48 giving me 18 which is an integer that means statement II is also correct. Why is that considered wrong?

I would consider 18 and 12 itself as x and y. If you do that, it is clearly not divisible by 48.

When considering multiples, you considered 18x2, that 2 is making it divisible by 48. Whenever you’re trying to consider multiples of a number, try to consider numbers like 18x13 or 18x7, basically multiply with primes which do not affect your answer.

Ahhh okay, thank you for the advice! However, I did multiply by prime numbers to both 18 and 12. I did 18x2=36 and 12x3=36. In statement II the 36x36=1296. I then divide 1296/4= 27 making statement II correct. I am still confused as to why it wouldn’t be correct since I am multiplying 18 and 12 by the prime numbers 2 and 3.

Sorry, I meant primes in the sense that the numbers which might not alter your answer. Like 2 and 3 will clearly do. Because 48 is a multiple of both 2 and 3. Whereas a number like 7,13, or 17 will be a safe bet. As you can see 18x12 is clearly not divisible by 48. So (18x7)x(12x13) will also not be divisible. But (18x2)x(12x3) will be because of that 2. So be careful

Oh okay I see, I understand what you mean. Thank you for your help!