Combinatorial Reasoning

The solution looks like easy but I’m really losing my mind solving it or I’m stupid

According to chatgpt,we have to choose those options which are divisible to 2 and 3 and at the same time doesn’t go up 16. So to save time, I only chose 6 and 12 but got chose 10,4 for m and 6,12 for c . My confusion is why it is choosing different options for both subjects? Shouldn’t the chosen numbers be the same? What is the problem in taking same numbers like 6,12 for both C and M??
I hope,I’ve made my problems clear.

I know,my handwriting is too bad

P.S. I didn’t get reply for verbal problem yesterday,Looking forward to hearing from you guys soon

We can’t read the question lol

I googled the question so i can see what you’re referring to.
|
Anyways, i think you have a misunderstanding here.

Let: \frac 12 M = \text{used}_1 and \frac 23C = \text{used}_2

Thus: \text{used}_{\text{total}} = \text{used}_1 + \text{used}_2 = \frac 12 M + \frac 23 C

The answer choices given are referring to the value of \textbf{used}_{\textbf{total}} and not the values of M and C (like you’ve used).

For example, if we consider option C as the \textbf{used}_{\textbf{total}}, then we’d have:
\textbf{used}_{\textbf{total}} = 6 = \frac 12M + \frac 23 C

We also have the constraint: M + C = 16, thus solving both gives us M = 28 and C = -12, which makes no sense so C doesn’t work.

What?? the snap I uploaded isn’t clear?? Negative answers?? I didn’t get one of them negative?

I appreciate your response but I am sorry I didn’t get it yet

No the question you posted had formatting issues. Try reading the image (question) you posted, but anyway i got the actual question, so that’s fine.

The answers from A to G are the total used (as i mentioned in my previous response), so you’re dealing with something like:

\frac 12 M + \frac 13 C = \text{one of the answer choices}

I don’t know why it is difficult to understand :pensive:bdw, thanks I will give it a shot once again

But i don’t understand what’s difficult to understand? I didn’t even ask a question though… i’m asking what you wrote if you look at the annotated image.

Hi, would you mind showing your method step by step, please? I’m still unable to understand this math

Do you agree that \frac 12 the math books and \frac 23 of the chem books are used?

This gives you \text{used}_{total} = \frac 12 M + \frac 23 C, right?

Yes I do agree ,then?

I’m guessing you also agree that M + C = 16 because that’s stated in the question.

One more thing you have to note is that the answer choices (A - H) are supposed to be answers for \text{used}_{\text{total}}.

Does both of this make sense to you?

Yes make sense, then?

I’m sorry for replying late

Okay so you had \text{used}_{\text{total}} = \frac 12 M + \frac 23 C, and you can substitute the value of C from M + C = 16 to get an expression for \text{used}_{\text{total}} solely in terms of M.

After that, you can quickly verify which answer works by considering the bounds on M:

0 < M < 16

I’ll leave this part for you to carry out

1 Like

I just can’t believe that I made the whole math complicated when the concept is easy as abc. How could I be such a brainless!:smiling_face_with_tear:

Didn’t you feel irritated by my question? Anyway,thanks Cylverix for tolerating me. Thanks a lot❤️

1 Like